Despite years of learning, foreign language learners make mistakes but rectify others: Reveals study

According to the study, foreign langauge learners are bound to hear errors in pronunciation peers make but repeat the mistakes themselves despite years of practice. The study showed that this practice may lead to betteer ways of providing external feedback in language courses.

Foreign-Language-Learners Pronunciation-Errors Peers-Mock-At-Each-Other

The researchers, including those from Ludwig Maximilian University (LMU) of Munich in Germany, said one of the difficulties faced by foreign language learners is to know the right way to pronounce words, typically in which learners make specific sets of errors.

The study, published in the journal PLOS One revealed that people mock at their fellow learners when they mis-pronounce words but continue to repeat same mistakes themselves.

According to researchers, this reaction projects paradox in which learners clicks on errors when made by others, but even after years of practice they find it virtually impossible to eliminate the same typical errors in their own pronunciation.

Also Read: Researchers of IIT Madras develops AI to convert brain signals into English language

"Learners have a tendency to overestimate the quality of their own pronunciation," said Eva Reinisch, study co-author from LMU.

Reinisch said, "As a rule, they believe that their English is better than that spoken by their fellow students at language schools, although they make the same set of errors."

According to the study, this put emphasis on assessment of one's own ability is a significant factor explaining why it is difficult to learn the sounds of a foreign language. To reach on better results, the scientists asked 24 female German learners of English to read out 60 short sentences like "The family bought a house," "The jug is on the shelf," and "They heard a funny noise."

The same learners were invited to the lab again for some weeks and asked to listen to recordings of four learners; three from others, and one of their own and were asked to grade the pronunciation of each sentence. However, the recordings were manipulated in such a way that the female speakers sounded like male speakers to ensure that participants would not recognise their own productions, the study noted.

"This element of the experimental design is crucial. It was essential that none of listeners would be aware that their own productions were included in the test sample, otherwise their assessments couldn't be taken as unbiased," said Holger Mitterer, another co-author of the study from the University of Malta in Malta.

It has been observed by researchers that the listeners, in all cases, rated their own pronunciation as better than others did, even when they were unable to recognise that it was their own recording. "We were surprised that the experiment so clearly pointed to the significance of overestimation of one's own abilities in this context," Reinisch added.

The researchers said such results could be due to familiar accents being easier to understand than accents that are less commonly spoken.

"One is best acquainted with the sound of one's own voice, and has no difficulty understanding it. Perhaps this familiarity leads us to regard our pronunciation as being better than it actually is," said Reinisch.

Scientists said another possible factor contributing to the finding is known as the 'mere exposure' effect in which people rate things which they are more familiar with, such as the sound of our own voice -- as more congenial.

The findings, according to the researchers, emphasise the importance of external feedback in language courses, since it increases the learners awareness of deficits in language production and comprehension. A lack of feedback, according to the study, increases the risk of learners feeling that they have already mastered the unfamiliar articulation patterns in the new language, while that may not be the case.

"As long as we believe that we are already pretty good, we are not going to put in more effort to improve," Reinisch said.


 


Trending